Back to home
Monday, 16 November 2026

The use of self: making the subjective present without making the self the subject

The use of self: making the subjective present without making the self the subject

A place to start

I want to start by confessing to a penchant for the confessional. Not with a priest and a promise of forgiveness but with an imagined audience for my writing and a promise of something making more sense at the end of the confessing moment. This means I tend to use some personal moment, experience, or observation as the basis for my writing and thinking. This feels natural to me. Indeed, it makes quite a bit of sense as I found systems psychodynamics whilst searching for meaning amidst the maelstrom of dysfunctional organisational dynamics. I have subsequently written, and worked, my way through some taxing situations.

Over time, I have found myself on the border of my own comfort levels with this style of writing. I wonder, for example, am I sharing too much? I also believe there is great value in mining our experience for broader meaning. My experience of organisational dysfunction is not only my experience, it also represents something of organisational culture, of leadership, and of social functioning. Writing about our experiences can serve many purposes, to explore a field or a concept and to engage in a type of conversational relationship. Using ourselves as instruments is serious and valuable work. How do we bring ourselves to it without being preoccupied with ourselves?

The challenge, then, is to make the subjective present without making myself the subject.

A confession

I was facilitating a workshop with a small group of staff who, although they work together on a common task, have individual tasks that require their attention the majority of the time. This workplace operates largely online. The in-person workshop was an opportunity to build relationships, develop stronger bonds to the shared task, and do some collaborative work on broader umbrella items that would strengthen the organisation. The workshop had been scheduled several months in advance. Approximately eight weeks prior to the workshop an issue emerged within the broader context of this particular industry that it was felt this group should be engaged with for individual, group, and organisational level thinking and action. Time was given to it in the workshop and resources (relevant context and an ask) were sought from the client. Nothing emerged. Prompts and reminders were sent closer to the date. All that was forthcoming were complaints at the need to deal with the issue.

In the days before the workshop I was frustrated and annoyed at the laissez-faire approach the client was taking. I chose to not independently research the issue believing the client would realise their input was needed and they would ‘take up their authority and engage’. A one page document arrived one hour after the workshop began, along with the apparent expectation the issue still be discussed. I had no time to read the brief, decipher what was being asked, or plan an approach. The team and I read it together and a thoughtful discussion, within the confines of the situation, was had and input offered back to the client. Bubbling beneath the surface, however, were increased levels of frustration, annoyance, and offence. I was heartily offended that such little care or interest could be taken of the team or of my role with the team. My desire in the days immediately following the workshop was to walk away and, riding that wave, I put some distance between myself and the client.

The relationship, however, is an ongoing one and the question returns to the challenge above, how do I make the subjective present without making myself the subject? Or, what do I do with this reaction?

A doorway

I was angry and offended and I wanted to withdraw. Ordinarily we’d be expected to get over these personal feelings. To manage them externally to the work, to regulate our responses and not let them interfere, to dismiss them. Using ourselves as instruments in the work, however, suggests that these feelings are not simply to be dismissed but rather that they are admissible data for use within an inquiry. Using ourselves as instruments in the work tells us that this form of data is legitimate and it is worth attending to.

Attending to it requires us to stretch both our minds and our care toward the data. Rather than turn away, we must give it our curiosity and carefully consider what it might be indicating. An opportunity to understand something as yet unspoken within the organisation may become apparent with such effort. In this case, my offence and desire to turn away from the client led to a temporary incapacity to engage in on-task activity. As I turn carefully toward this incapacity, some of the questions for the client might then become: what has become too difficult for the organisation to look at or engage with, how has it become too difficult, and what is the organisation therefore not doing, or not doing well enough?

I have thoughts on this. At the moment, though, the point is that experience becomes legitimate, observable, interrogable, and meaningful data. Experience and associated feelings and emotions are not a verdict or the end of a conversation. They do not prove an organisation is offensive or wrong, or in different circumstances entirely amazing and the answer to everything. Neither, however, are they dismissed as merely personal. They inform the next conversation.

A conundrum

There’s an interesting little sticking point in this and it revolves around a question: is this data ‘just me’ or ‘is it the organisation’? It can be easy to split the experience in this way and understand it as all one way or the other. Having deep knowledge of ourselves is important here. What are my peccadilloes, my familiar patterns of behaviour? It helps to be able to recognise when my behaviour is following a well-known trajectory, when it may be amplified, or when it is completely unlike me. Using ourselves as instruments means we build capabilities to catch these moments, feel the feelings, and come back with genuine curiosity. Then we become better able to see the multiple influences at play in an interaction and the ways in which they become entangled; rather than this or that it becomes this and that.

It goes further still, it’s not simply the entanglement of this and that out there in the client organisation, it is also this (me) and that (the organisation). We are entangled.

Towards collaboration

What does this entanglement of reaction and organisational dynamics tell us about our capacity to collaborate? If the organisation and I are both pulled to withdraw, what happens to our ability, our willingness, to stay engaged with the joint tasks before us? The beginning of a working hypothesis for work with my client emerges here: it is not only the specific issue we were tasked with discussing but also the experience of elements of the external environment and the manner in which it is perceived as being persecutory, that need attention. These thoughts around a working hypothesis consider the client may be experiencing significant persecutory anxiety in relation to the demands of the external environment and this anxiety is infusing the client system with counterproductive working habits. I begin to formulate the hypothesis through the counterproductive working habits I can see within the system: the organisation turning away from external demands, providing material for a conversation only after that conversation has begun, and my own desire to turn away, followed by the act of doing so.

When we are busy enacting such counterproductive behaviour, how do we collaborate? It’s a good question, and I don’t have a good enough response at the moment as I have not yet figured out how collaboration works here. This doesn’t make it a moot point, it makes it a fruitful site for exploration, perhaps the site that most needs exploration. I feel a new working hypothesis coming on…

Further reading and learning

Have you been reading organisations all your working life?

The Ladder of Layered Learning at NIODA.

Related insights

Read the post Have you been reading organisations all your working life?
thomas mitchell Monday, 12 October 2026

Have you been reading organisations all your working life?

Ever wonder why formal plans rarely match workplace reality? Discover how reading organisations and systems psychodynamics turn curiosity into disciplined leadership

Read the post Walking Together: Reflections from the Walk for Truth
sally mussared Wednesday, 8 July 2026

Walking Together: Reflections from the Walk for Truth

A wet Canberra morning at the Walk for Truth sparked a question: could walking together transform how teams connect, converse and reflect?

Read the post Slow Down to Lead: The Reflective Edge in Leadership and Management
Wednesday, 24 June 2026

Slow Down to Lead: The Reflective Edge in Leadership and Management

Most leaders know something important is being lost in the pace of modern work. The capacity to think clearly, read the room, and lead with genuine presence gets crowded out by meetings, deliverables, and the pressure to always appear in control. Slow Down to Lead explores the reflective edge in leadership — what it means to pause without stopping, why emotion is data not distraction, and how developing a reflective practice changes not just how you lead, but how you see.